| 945 | 15 | 270 |
| 下载次数 | 被引频次 | 阅读次数 |
文章从以往研究出发,归纳出上下级信任的三种理论视角,分别是社会身份的理论视角、社会认知的理论视角和社会交换的理论视角。社会身份这一视角强调上下级之间的相似性,包括社会类别的相似性和信息的相似性,是上下级信任建立的基础和起点;社会认知视角关注了信任方对被信任方行为特征、人格类型以及双方关系和情境的认知分析,进而做出信任的决策。上述两种理论视角都以信任方为信任主体,强调信任建立在信任方对被信任方判断的基础上,而社会交换视角下的信任则从信任双方的互动出发,探究信任如何在双方社会交换的互动过程中得以建立。文章将以往领导和下属信任的研究通过上述三种理论视角加以分类,旨在总结归纳领导下属间信任研究的全貌并对现存的问题提出了建议,指明了未来可能的研究发展方向。
Abstract：Based on previous literatures on trust between leaders and subordinates,we generalized the researches from three theoretical perspectives,namely,similarity derived from social identity theory,social cognition theory and social exchange theory.The former two perspectives focused on the trustor as the sponsor of trust relationship,while social exchange theory keeps a watchful eye on the interaction of both trustors and trustees,namely: leaders and subordinates. To be concrete,social identity theory laid the foundation of trust,thus similarity is the basis for building trust between leaders and subordinates,including similarities in social category and similarities in information aspects. From the perspective of social cognition theory,trustors make their decisions of whether they should trust others by judging the information about the characteristics of trustees,the relationship between them and the contexts. Lastly,when we mention trust from the perspective of social exchange theory,we focus on the whole set-up process of exchange relationship,in other words,the process of the interaction between leaders and subordinates and how they build trust along the process. In conclusion,we show the whole picture of researches on trust between leaders and subordinates with the lens of three perspectives. Moreover,by illustrating the limitations of current literatures,we lead a direction for further research.
[1]CRONBACH L J,MEEHL P E.Construct validity in psychological tests[J].Psychological Bulletin,1955,52(4):281.
[2]BURKE C S,SIMS D E,LAZZARA E H,et al.Trust in leadership:a multi-level review and integration[J].The Leadership Quarterly,2007,18(6):606-632.
[3]MCALLISTER D J.Affectand cognition-based trust as foundations for interpersonal cooperation in organizations[J].Academy of Management Journal,1995,38(1):24-59.
[4]MAYER R C,DAVIS J H,SCHOORMAN F D.An integrative model of organizational trust[J].Academy of Management Review,1995,20(3):709-734.
[5]PODSAKOFF P M,MACKENZIE S B,MOORMAN R H,et al.Transformational leader behaviors and their effects On followers'trust in leader,satisfaction,and organizational citizenship behaviors[J].The Leadership Quarterly,1990,1(2):107-142.
[6]JUNG D I,AVOLIO B J.Opening the black box:an experimental investigation of the mediating effects of trust and value congruence on transformational and transactional leadership[J].Journal of Organizational Behavior,2000,21(8):949-964.
[7]SETTOON R P,MOSSHOLDER K W.Relationship quality and relationship context as antecedents of person-and task-focused interpersonal citizenship behavior[J].Journal of Applied Psychology,2002,87(2):255.
[8]DIRKS K T,FERRIN D L.Trust in leadership:meta-analytic findings and implications for research and practice.[J].Journal of Applied Psychology.2002,87(4):611-628.
[9]BLAU P M.Exchange and power in social life[M].New York:Transaction Publishers,1964:7-29.
[10]SCHRIESHEIM C A,CASTRO S L,COGLISER C C.Leader-member exchange(LMX)research:a comprehensive review of theory,measurement,and data-analytic practices[J].The Leadership Quarterly,1999,10(1):63-113.
[11]WHITENER E M,BRODT S E,KORSGAARD M A,et al.Managers as initiators of trust:an exchange relationship framework for understanding managerial trustworthy behavior[J].Academy of Management Review,1998,23(3):513-530.
[12]章志光,金盛华.社会心理学[M].北京:人民教育出版社,1996:56-59.
[13]柯江林,孙健敏.R&D团队人际信任的影响因素[J].经济管理,2007(19):55-59.
[14]HILTON J L,Von HIPPEL W.Stereotypes[J].Annual Review of Psychology.1996,47(1):237-271.
[15]VAN KNIPPENBERG D.Embodying who we are:leader group prototypicality and leadership effectiveness[J].The Leadership Quarterly,2011,22(6):1078-1091.
[16]TAJFEL H,TURNER J C.An integrative theory of intergroup conflict[J].The Social Psychology of Intergroup Relations,1979,33(47):74.
[17]COOK J,WALL T.New work attitude measures of trust,organizational commitment and personal need non-fulfilment[J].Journal of Occupational Psychology,1980,53(1):39-52.
[18]SMITH K G,SMITH K A,OLIAN J D,et al.Top management team demography and process:the role of social integration and communication[J].Administrative Science Quarterly,1994,39(3):412-438.
[19]CVETKOVICH G,LOFSTEDT R.Social trust and the management of risk london:earthscan[M].London:Earthscan,1999:12-24.
[20]LAU D C,LIU J,FU P P.Feeling trusted by business leaders in China:antecedents and the mediating role of value congruence[J].Asia Pacific Journal of Management,2007,24(3):321-340.
[21]SIEGRIST M,CVETKOVICH G,ROTH C.Salient value similarity,social trust,and risk/benefit perception[J].Risk analysis,2000,20(3):353-362.
[22]JUNG D I,AVOLIO B J.Opening the black box:an experimental investigation of the mediating effects of trust and value congruence on transformational and transactional leadership[J].Journal of Organizational Behavior.2000,21(8):949-964.
[23]FUKUYAMA F,彭志华.信任:社会美德与创造经济繁荣[M].海口:海南出版社,2001:8-34.
[24]DELHEY J,NEWTON K.Predicting cross-national levels of social trust:global pattern or nordic exceptionalism?[J].European Sociological Review,2005,21(4):311-327.
[25]HOGG M A,VAN KNIPPENBERG D,RAST D E.The social identity theory of leadership:Theoretical origins,research findings,and conceptual developments[J].European Review of Social Psychology,2012,23(1):258-304.
[26]王重鸣,邓靖松.团队中信任形成的映象决策机制[J].心理学报.2007(2):321-327.
[27]BALLINGER G A,SCHOORMAN F D,LEHMAN D W.Will you trust your new boss?the role of affective reactions to leadership succession[J].The Leadership Quarterly,2009,20(2):219-232.
[28]LAPIDOT Y,KARK R,SHAMIR B.The impact of situational vulnerability on the development and erosion of followers'trust in their leader[J].The Leadership Quarterly,2007,18(1):16-34.
[29]韩振华,乐国安.信任的心理学研究与展望[J].西南大学学报(社会科学版),2009(2):1-5.
[30]BUTLER J K,CANTRELL R S,FLICK R J.Transformational leadership behaviors,upward trust,and satisfaction in selfmanaged work teams.[J].Organization Development Journal,1999,17(1):13-28.
[31]KARAKOWSKY L,DEGAMA N,MCBEY K.Facilitating the pygmalion effect:the overlooked role of subordinate perceptions of the leader[J].Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology,2012,85(4):579-599.
[32]DULEBOHN J H,BOMMER W H,LIDEN R C,et al.A meta-analysis of antecedents and consequences of leader-member exchange integrating the past with an eye toward the future[J].Journal of Management,2012,38(6):1715-1759.
[33]BROWER H H,LESTER S W,KORSGAARD M A,et al.A closer look at trust between managers and subordinates:understanding the effects of both trusting and being trusted on subordinate outcomes[J].Journal of Management,2009,35(2):327-347.
[34]MISHRA A K,SPREITZER G M.Explaining how survivors respond to downsizing:the roles of trust,empowerment,justice,and work redesign[J].Academy of management Review,1998,23(3):567-588.
[35]杨慧琳.组织中领导与下属双向信任的作用机制研究[D].广州:暨南大学管理学院,2011.
[36]BUTLER J K.Toward understanding and measuring conditions of trust:evolution of a conditions of trust inventory[J].Journal of Management,1991,17(3):643-663.
[37]CONGER J A,KANUNGO R N.Charismatic leadership in organizations[J].Administrative Science Quarterly,1998,46(1):163-168.
[38]AVOLIO B J,JUNGDI,MURRY W,et al.Building highly developed teams:focusing on shared leadership process,efficacy,trust,and performance[C]∥BEYERLEIN M M,JOHNSON D A,BEYERLEN S T.Advances in interdisciplinary studies of work teams.Greenwich,CT:JAI Press,1996:173-209.
[39]FERRIS G R,LIDEN R C,MUNYON T P,et al.Relationships at work:toward a multidimensional conceptualization of dyadic work relationships[J].Journal of Management,2009,35(6):1379-1403.
[40]颜士梅,陈丽哲,张钢.团队中人际信任动态性的实证研究[J].软科学,2013(12):45-48.
[41]KELLEY K M,BISEL R S.Leaders'narrative sensemaking during LMX role negotiations:explaining how leaders make sense of who to trust and when[J].The Leadership Quarterly,2014,25(3):433-448.
[42]俞达,梁钧平.对领导者-成员交换理论(LMX)的重新检验——一个新的理论模型[J].经济科学,2002(1):5-18.
[43]LIDEN R C,GRAEN G.Generalizability of the vertical dyad linkage model of leadership[J].Academy of Management Journal.1980,23(3):451-465.
[44]LIDEN R C,SPARROWE R T,WAYNE S J.Leader-member exchange theory:the past and potential for the future[J].Research in Personnel&Human Resources Management,1997,22(2):522-552.
[45]SPARROWE R T,LIDEN R C.Process and structure in leader-member exchange[J].Academy of Management Review,1997,22(2):522-552.
[46]ZAND D E.Trust and managerial problem solving[J].Administrative Science Quarterly,1972,17(2):229-239.
[47]TORCHE F,VALENZUELA E.Trust and reciprocity:a theoretical distinction of the sources of social capital[J].European Journal of Social Theory,2011,14(2):181-198.
[48]PODSAKOFF P M,MACKENZIE S B,BOMMER W H.Transformational leader behaviors and substitutes for leadership as determinants of employee satisfaction,commitment,trust,and organizational citizenship behaviors[J].Journal of Management,1996,22(2):259-298.
[49]CICERO L,PIERRO A,van KNIPPENBERG D.Leadership and uncertainty:how role ambiguity affects the relationship between leader group prototypicality and leadership effectiveness[J].British Journal of Management,2010,21(2):411-421.
[50]BASADUR M,GRAEN G B,GREEN S G.Training in creative problem solving:effects on ideation and problem finding and solving in an industrial research organization[J].Organizational Behavior and Human Performance,1982,30(1):41-70.
[51]DIENESCH R M,LIDEN R C.Leader-member exchange model of leadership:a critique and further development[J].Academy of Management Review,1986,11(3):618-634.
[52]SIMONS T.GAIL T FAIRHURST.Discursive leadership:in conversation with leadership psychology[J].Administrative Science Quarterly,2009,54(1):162-164.
[53]费孝通.乡土中国[M].上海:上海人民出版社,2007:9-14.
[54]杨中芳,彭泗清.中国人人际信任的概念化:一个人际关系的观点[J].社会学研究,1999(2):3-23.
[55]BHAGAT R S,TRIANDIS H C,MCDEVITT A S.Managing global organizations:a cultural perspective[J].Annals of the Rheumatic Diseases,2012,74(1):973-974.
[56]CHATURVEDI S,GAUR A.A Dynamic Model of Trust and Commitment Development in Strategic Alliances[J].IIMB Management Review,2009,21(3):173-188.
[57]KRAMER R M.Trust and distrust in organizations:emerging perspectives,enduring questions[J].Annual Review of Psychology,1999,50(1):569-598.
[58]HOGG M A,TERRY D I.Social identity and self-categorization processes in organizational contexts[J].Academy of Management Review,2000,25(1):131-140.
[59]辛自强,辛素飞.被信任者社会身份复杂性对其可信性的影响[J].心理学报,2014(3):415-426.
[60]EMPSON L.Organizational identity change:managerial regulation and member identification in an accounting firm acquisition[J].Accounting,Organizations and Society,2004,29(8):759-781.
[61]颜士梅.创业型并购中的知识员工整合风险研究[M].杭州:科学出版社,2013:12-37.
[62]GRAEBNER M E.Caveat venditor:trust asymmetries in acquisitions of entrepreneurial firms[J].Academy of Management Journal,2009,52(3):435-472.
[63]LEWICKI R J,BUNKER B B.Trust in relationships:a model of development and decline[M].San Francisco:Jossey-Bass,1995:45-62.
[64]STAHL G K,LARSSON R,KREMERSHOF I,et al.Trust dynamics in acquisitions:a case survey[J].Human Resource Management,2011,50(5):575-603.
[65]LANDER M W,KOONING L.Boarding the aircraft:trust development amongst negotiators of a complex merger[J].Journal of Management Studies,2013,50(1):1-30.
基本信息:
DOI：10.14134/j.cnki.cn33-1336/f.2017.04.005
中图分类号:F272.92
引用信息:
[1]颜士梅,陈丽哲.领导下属间信任研究:三个理论视角[J].商业经济与管理,2017,No.306(04):49-56.DOI:10.14134/j.cnki.cn33-1336/f.2017.04.005.
基金信息:
国家自然科学基金项目“并购情景下领导一成员资源交换及其对离职意愿的双重影响机制”(项目号为71672171)
2017-05-03
2017-05-03
2017-05-03