| 1,071 | 18 | 268 |
| 下载次数 | 被引频次 | 阅读次数 |
“逐利”还是“重情”,寓意着家族企业在代际传承过程中更加重视财务目标还是更加重视社会情感财富目标。这是家族企业在目标决策中经常面临的一个困境。然而现有研究对这一现象及其背后的影响机制缺乏足够的重视，因此文章区分家族企业代际传承的不同阶段，研究企业目标问题。利用2006—2021年A股上市家族企业样本，实证研究发现：在代际传承期间，家族企业对不同目标的重视程度具有动态性，即接班准备阶段更偏向SEW目标，随着二代接班上位则更偏向财务目标。这一结论在经过一系列稳健性检验之后依然成立，并且证实企业风险承担水平是代际传承中目标决策的影响机制。进一步检验发现，在代际传承的不同阶段，创始人任职情况也会对企业目标产生影响。最后，文章发现家族企业对于SEW目标的偏向是有代价的，表现为企业绩效折损。
Abstract：To pursue profit or to value socioemotional wealth (SEW) implies that family businesses place greater emphasis on financial goals or socioemotional wealth goals in the process of intergenerational succession.However,the existing research lacks due attention to this phenomenon and its influence mechanism.Therefore,this paper distinguishes the different stages of intergenerational succession of family firms and studies the enterprise goals.Using the sample of A-share listed family firms from 2006 to 2021,the empirical study finds that:during the intergenerational succession period,family firm's goal preferences are dynamic,that is,the SEW goals are preferred before the second generation takes over the family firm,and the financial goals are preferred after the second generation becomes a real leader.This conclusion is still valid after a series of robustness tests,and it is confirmed that the level of enterprise risk bearing is the impact mechanism of goal decision-making in intergenerational succession.Further examination finds that at different stages of intergenerational succession,the tenure of founders also has an impact on family firms'goals.Finally,this paper finds that the preference of family firms for SEW goals comes at a cost and will lead to some loss in business performance.
[1]祝振铎，李新春，赵勇．父子共治与创新决策---中国家族企业代际传承中的父爱主义与深谋远虑效应[J]．管理世界，2021(9):191-207,232．
[2]李新春，韩剑，李炜文．传承还是另创领地?---家族企业二代继承的权威合法性建构[J]．管理世界，2015(6):110-124,187-188．
[3]DE MASSIS A,CHUA J H,CHRISMAN J J.Factors preventing intra-family succession[J].Family Business Review,2008,21(2):183-199．
[4]STEIER L P,MILLER D.Pre-and post-succession governance philosophies in entrepreneurial family firms[J].Journal of Family Business Strategy,2010,1(3):145-154．
[5]ZELLWEGER T M,NASON R S.A stakeholder perspective on family firm performance[J].Family Business Review,2008,21(3):203-216．
[6]GóMEZ-MEJíA L R,HAYNES K T,N?EZ-NICKEL M,et al.Socioemotional wealth and business risks in family-controlled firms:evidence from Spanish olive oil mills[J].Administrative Science Quarterly,2007,52(1):106-137．
[7]GóMEZ-MEJíA L R,PATEL P C,ZELLWEGER T M.In the horns of the dilemma:socioemotional wealth,financial wealth,and acquisitions in family firms[J].Journal of Management,2018,44(4):1369-1397．
[8]吴炯．家族涉入，家族理性与家族企业目标偏好---基于一项比较案例的探索[J]．商业经济与管理，2012(5):23-30．
[9]姜涛，杨明轩，王晗．制度环境、二代涉入与目标二元性---来自中国家族上市公司的证据[J]．南开管理评论，2019,22(4):135-147．
[10]CABRERA-SUáREZ M K,DéNIZ-DéNIZ M D L C,MARTíN-SANTANA J D.The setting of non-financial goals in the family firm:the influence of family climate and identification[J].Journal of Family Business Strategy,2014,5(3):289-299．
[11]HAUCK J,PRüGL R.Innovation activities during intra-family leadership succession in family firms:an empirical study from a socioemotional wealth perspective[J].Journal of Family Business Strategy,2015,6(2):104-118．
[12]晁上．论家族企业权力的代际传递[J]．南开管理评论，2002(5):47-51．
[13]祝振铎，李新春，叶文平．“扶上马、送一程”:家族企业代际传承中的战略变革与父爱主义[J]．管理世界，2018(11):65-79,196．
[14]CHRISMAN J J,CHUA J H,PEARSON A W,et al.Family involvement,family influence,and family-centered non-economic goals in small firms[J].Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice,2012,36(2):267-293．
[15]KOTLAR J,DE MASSIS A.Goal setting in family firms:goal diversity,social interactions,and collective commitment to familycentered goals[J].Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice,2013,37(6):1263-1288．
[16]ZELLWEGER T M,NASON R S,NORDQVIST M,et al.Why do family firms strive for nonfinancial goals?An organizational identity perspective[J].Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice,2013,37(2):229-248．
[17]BERRONE P,CRUZ C,GóMEZ-MEJíA L R.Socioemotional wealth in family firms:theoretical dimensions,assessment approaches,and agenda for future research[J].Family Business Review,2012,25(3):258-279．
[18]ANDERSON R C,REEB D M.Founding-family ownership and firm performance:evidence from the S&P 500[J].The Journal of Finance,2003,58(3):1301-1328．
[19]LE BRETON-MILLER I,MILLER D.Why do some family businesses out-compete?Governance,long-term orientations,and sustainable capability[J].Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice,2006,30(6):731-746．
[20]MARTIN G P,GóMEZ-MEJíA L R,WISEMAN RM.Executive stock options as mixed gambles:revisiting the behavioral agency model[J].Academy of Management Journal,2013,56(2):451-472．
[21]GóMEZ-MEJíA L R,CRUZ C,BERRONE P,DE CASTRO J.The bind that ties:socioemotional wealth preservation in family firms[J].Academy of Management Annals,2011,5(1):653-707．
[22]BERRONE P,CRUZ C,GóMEZ-MEJíA L R,et al.Socioemotional wealth and corporate responses to institutional pressures:do family-controlled firms pollute less?[J].Administrative Science Quarterly,2010,55(1):82-113．
[23]GóMEZ-MEJíA L R,MAKRI M,KINTANA M L.Diversification decisions in family-controlled firms[J].Journal of Management Studies,2010,47(2):223-252．
[24]GóMEZ-MEJíA L R,CAMPBELL J T,MARTIN G,et al.Socioemotional wealth as a mixed gamble:revisiting family firm R&Dinvestments with the behavioral agency model[J].Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice,2014,38(6):1351-1374．
[25]刘子旭，王满．代际传承背景下家族企业继任二代创新投入水平研究---基于差序格局视角[J]．商业经济与管理，2021(12):80-96．
[26]CHRISMAN J J,MEMILI E,MISRA K.Nonfamily managers,family firms,and the winner's curse:the influence of noneconomic goals and bounded rationality[J].Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice,2014,38(5):1-25．
[27]CHRISMAN J J,PATEL P C.Variations in R&D investments of family and nonfamily firms:behavioral agency and myopic loss aversion perspectives[J].Academy of Management Journal,2012,55(4):976-997．
[28]BOELLIS A,MARIOTTI S,MINICHILLI A,et al.Family involvement and firms'establishment mode choice in foreign markets[J].Journal of International Business Studies,2016,47(8):929-950．
[29]DE MASSIS A,KOTLAR J,MAZZOLA P,etal.Conflicting selves:family owners'multiple goals and self-control agency problems in private firms[J].Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice,2018,42(3):362-389．
[30]LIDEN R C.Leadership research in Asia:a brief assessment and suggestions for the future[J].Asia Pacific Journal of Management,2012,29(2):205-212．
[31]DOU J,WANG N,SU E,et al.Goal complexity in family firm diversification:evidence from China[J].Journal of Family Business Strategy,Elsevier,2020,11(1):1-12．
[32]胡旭阳，吴一平．创始人政治身份与家族企业控制权的代际锁定[J]．中国工业经济，2017(5):152-171．
[33]YAN J,SORENSON R L.The influence of confucian ideology on conflict in Chinese family business[J].International Journal of Cross Cultural Management,2004,4(1):5-17．
[34]陈凌，陈华丽．家族涉入、社会情感财富与企业慈善捐赠行为---基于全国私营企业调查的实证研究[J]．管理世界，2014(8):90-101,188．
[35]FAN J P H,JIAN M,YEH Y H.Succession:the roles of specialized assets and transfer costs[R].Hong Kong:The Chinese University of Hong Kong,2007．
[36]窦军生，贾生华．“家业”何以长青?---企业家个体层面家族企业代际传承要素的识别[J]．管理世界，2008(9):105-117．
[37]HE W,YU X.Paving the way for children:family firm succession and corporate philanthropy in China[J].Journal of Business Finance&Accounting,2019,46(9-10):1237-1262．
[38]魏春燕，陈磊．家族企业CEO更换过程中的利他主义行为---基于资产减值的研究[J]．管理世界，2015(3):137-150．
[39]KAMMERLANDER N,SIEGER P,VOORDECKERS W,et al.Value creation in family firms:a model of fit[J].Journal of Family Business Strategy,2015,6(2):63-72．
[40]WILLIAMS JR R I,PIEPER T M,KELLERMANNS F W,et al.Family firm goals and their effects on strategy,family and organization behavior:a review and research agenda[J].International Journal of Management Reviews,2018,20(1):S63-S82．
[41]SCIASCIA S,MAZZOLA P,KELLERMANNS F W.Family management and profitability in private family-owned firms:introducing generational stage and the socioemotional wealth perspective[J].Journal of Family Business Strategy,2014,5(2):131-137．
[42]VILLALONGA B,AMIT R.How do family ownership,control and management affect firm value?[J].Journal of Financial Economics,2006,80(2):385-417．
[43]BENNEDSEN M,NIELSEN K M,PéREZ-GONZáLEZ F,et al.Inside the family firm:the role of families in succession decisions and performance[J].The Quarterly Journal of Economics,2007,122(2):647-691．
[44]LUMPKIN G T,BRIGHAM K H.Long-term orientation and intertemporal choice in family firms[J].Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice,2011,35(6):1149-1169．
[45]姜付秀，郑晓佳，蔡文婧．控股家族的“垂帘听政”与公司财务决策[J]．管理世界，2017(3):125-145．
[46]MOLLY V,LAVEREN E,DELOOF M.Family business succession and its impact on financial structure and performance[J].Family Business Review,2010,23(2):131-147．
[47]SMITH B F,AMOAKO-ADU B.Management succession and financial performance of family controlled firms[J].Journal of Corporate Finance,1999,5(4):341-368．
[48]WEI C.State ownership and target setting:evidence from publicly listed companies in China[J].Contemporary Accounting Research,2021,38(3):1925-1960．
[49]PREACHER K J,HAYES A F.Asymptotic and resampling strategies for assessing and comparing indirect effects in multiple mediator models[J].Behavior Research Methods,2008,40(3):879-891．
[50]许永斌，鲍树琛．代际传承对家族企业风险承担的影响[J]．商业经济与管理，2019(3):50-60．
[51]牛枫，张刘臻，肖作平．国有股权参股对民营企业风险承担水平的影响---基于上市民营企业的数据研究[J]．商业经济与管理，2022(9):72-89．
[52]CADIEUX L,LORRAIN J,HUGRON P.Succession in women-owned family businesses:a case study[J].Family Business Review,2002,15(1):17-30．
[53]赵晶，张书博，祝丽敏．传承人合法性对家族企业战略变革的影响[J]．中国工业经济，2015(8):130-144．
[54]FAN J P H,WONG T J,ZHANG T.Founder succession and accounting properties[J].Contemporary Accounting Research,2012,29(1):283-311．
[55]XU N,YUAN Q,JIANG X,et al.Founder's political connections,second generation involvement,and family firm performance:evidence from China[J].Journal of Corporate Finance,2015,33(3):243-259.
(1)2007年,中国证监会发布修订后的《公开发行证券的公司信息披露内容与格式准则第2号——年度报告的内容与格式》,要求上市公司在“董事会报告”部分的“对公司未来发展的展望”中披露新年度的经营计划,“包括(但不限于)收入、费用成本计划,及新年度的经营目标”。
(2)根据两位数的中国证监会行业代码组建行业规模的同行小组,将每个公司与一个行业规模的同行进行匹配,并计算公司的销售目标增长率与匹配同行公司销售额增长率之间的差异。
基本信息:
DOI：10.14134/j.cnki.cn33-1336/f.2023.03.004
中图分类号:F276.5;F832.51;C913.11
引用信息:
[1]许永斌,张爱兰.“逐利”还是“重情”:家族企业代际传承中的目标研究[J].商业经济与管理,2023,No.377(03):50-69.DOI:10.14134/j.cnki.cn33-1336/f.2023.03.004.
基金信息:
国家社会科学基金一般项目“基于供应链调整的企业海外并购战略研究”(20BGL030); 浙江省工商管理一流学科建设基金(1010JYN4118003G); 浙江省教育厅一般科研项目“共同富裕背景下家族企业的慈善捐赠行为研究”(Y202250474)
2023-03-15
2023-03-15